On the Implementation Path of Sustainable Development Principle in International Law

doi:10. 3969 / j. issn. 2096-2266. 2024. 01. 010

Abstract

Abstract: The principle of sustainable development has developed into a principle of international law for mankind to cope with global
challenges, but it faces various difficulties and challenges in the process of implementation. The fragmentation and softening of
international law norms in the field of sustainable development, and the rise of non-state actors have had a significant impact on the understanding and implementation of sustainable development principle. Through the systematization of international law on sustainable development and the updating of implementation theories and methods, it is necessary to improve the system of rules applicable to the principle of sustainable development, give play to the constructive role of non-state actors, and enhance the binding force and enforcement of the principle of sustainable development through international economic and trade treaties and dispute settlement mechanisms, so that the principle of sustainable development can be correctly implemented and enforced in international law.

Key words: , the principles of sustainable development, international law, systematization, softening of law, non-state actors

CLC Number:

Zhao Jianfu. On the Implementation Path of Sustainable Development Principle in International Law[J]. Journal of Dali University, 2024, 9(1): 64-74.

0
/ / Recommend

Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

URL: http://journal15.magtechjournal.com/Jwk_dlxyzk/EN/10. 3969 / j. issn. 2096-2266. 2024. 01. 010

http://journal15.magtechjournal.com/Jwk_dlxyzk/EN/Y2024/V9/I1/64

References

〔1〕王铁崖. 国际法引论〔M〕. 北京：北京大学出版社，1998：
3-4.
〔2〕路易斯·亨金. 国际法：政治与价值〔M〕. 张乃根，马忠
法，罗国强，等，译. 北京：中国政法大学出版社，2005：5.
〔3〕 XUE H Q. Transboundary Damage in International Law〔M〕.
Cambridge：Cambridge University Press，2003：325.
〔4〕“ 人类命运共同体与国际法”课题组. 人类命运共同体的
国际法构建〔J〕. 武大国际法评论，2019（1）：1-28.
〔5〕肖巍. 作为人权的环境权与可持续发展〔J〕. 哲学研究，
2005（11）：8-13.
〔6〕林灿铃. 国际环境法（第2版）〔M〕. 北京：人民出版社，
2011：34.
〔7〕 GILLESPIE A. The Illusion of Progress：Unsustainable De⁃
velopment in International Law and Policy〔M〕. London：
Earthscan Publications，2001：149-152.
〔8〕 UNEP. Global Environmental Outlook 〔M〕. Oxford：Oxford
University Press，1997：3.
〔9〕汉斯·摩根索. 国家间政治：权力斗争与和平（第七
版）〔M〕. 徐昕，郝望，李保平，译. 北京：北京大学出版
社，2006：353.
〔10〕联合国国际法委员会. 国际法不成体系问题：国际
法多样化和扩展引起的困难〔EB/OL〕. （2006-04-13）
〔2023-06-20〕. https：//documents - dds - ny.un.org/doc/
UNDOC/LTD/G06/610/76/PDF/G0661076. pdf? OpenEle⁃
ment.
〔11〕 WELLENS K. Fragmentation of International Law and Es⁃
tablishment of an Accountability Regime for International
Organizations 〔J〕. Michigan Journal of International Law，
2004（25）：1159-1181.
〔12〕克劳斯·博塞尔曼，等. 可持续发展的法律和政治〔M〕.
王曦，卢锟，等，译. 上海：上海交通大学出版社，2017：
术语表002-003.
〔13〕 BOYLE A E ，CHINKIN C. The Making of International
Law〔 M〕. Oxford：Oxford University Press，2007：211.
〔14〕 DUPUY P. Soft law and the international law of the envi⁃
ronment 〔J〕. Michigan Journal of International Law，1991
（12）：420-435.
〔15〕 SANDS P. Environmental Protection in the Twenty-First
Century：Sustainable Development and International Law
〔M〕 // N. J. Vig and R. S. Axelrod （eds.），The Global En⁃
vironment：Inst itutions，Law，and Policy. Washington：
Congressional Quarterly，1999：120.
〔16〕王绳祖. 国际关系史（第一卷）〔M〕. 北京：世界知识出
版社，1995：3.
〔17〕 HALL R B，BIERSTEKER T J. The Emergence of Private
Authority in Global Governance〔M〕.Cambridge：Cambridge
University Press，2002：4.
〔18〕星野昭吉，刘小林. 冷战后国际关系理论的变化与发
展：中日学者合作研究国际关系理论的成果〔M〕. 北
京：北京师范大学出版社，1999：53.
〔19〕 DAMROSCH L，MURPHY S. International Law：Cases and
Materials 〔M〕. 6th ed. West Publishing Co.，2014：426-
427.
〔20〕张文显. 法理学（第2版）〔M〕. 北京：高等教育出版社，
2003：441-442.
〔21〕 CASSIMATIS A E. International Humanitarian Law，Inter⁃
national Human Rights Law，and Fragmentation of Interna⁃
tional Law〔J〕. Int Comp Law Q，2007，56（3）：623-639.
〔22〕 BONANOMI E B. Sustainable Development in International
Law Making and Trade：International Food Governance
and Trade in Agriculture〔M〕. Cheltenham，UK：Edward
Elgar Publishing，2015：Foreword.
〔23〕 BARRAL V. Sustainable Development in International Law：
Nature and Operation of an Evolutive Legal Norm〔J〕. The
European Journal of International Law，2012，23（2）：377-
400.
〔24〕 PAUWELYN J. Conflict of Norms in Public International
Law：How WTO Law Relates to Other Rules of Interna⁃
tional Law〔M〕. Cambridge：Cambridge University Press，
2003：218.
〔25〕约翰·R. 诺朗，帕特里夏·E. 萨尔金. 气候变化与可持
续发展法精要〔M〕. 申进忠，曹彩丹，译. 天津：南开大
学出版社，2016：20.
〔26〕 INTERNATIONAL LAW ASSOCIATION. New Delhi Dec⁃
laration of Principles of International Law Relating to Sus⁃
tainable Development 〔EB/OL〕. （2002-08-09）〔2023-
06-20〕. http：//www2. ecolex. org/server2 neu. php/libcat/
docs/LI/MON-070850. pdf.
〔27〕 VOIGT C. Sustainable Development as a Principle of In⁃
ternational Law：Resolving Conflicts between Climate Mea⁃
sures and WTO Law〔M〕. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers，
2009：36.
〔28〕 BOYLE A，FREESTONE D. International Law and Sus⁃
tainable Development：Past Achievements and Future
Challenges〔M〕. New York：Oxford University Press，1999：
10-12.
〔29〕 FITZMAURICE M A. International Protection of the Envi⁃
ronment〔 J〕. Recueil des Cours，2001（9）：52-59.
〔30〕SEGGER M C，KHALFAN A. Sustainable Development
Law：Principles，Practices and Prospects〔 M〕. Oxford：Ox⁃
ford University Press，2004：45-47.
〔31〕 LOWE V. Sustainable Development and Unsustainable Ar⁃
guments〔M〕//Alan Boyle and David Freestone. Interna⁃
tional Law and Sustainable Development：Past Achieve⁃
ments and Future Challenges. New York：Oxford Univer⁃
sity Press，1999：31.
〔32〕 BONANOMI E B. Sustainable Development in Interna⁃
tional Law Making and Trade：International Food Gover⁃
nance and Trade in Agriculture 〔M〕. Cheltenham，UK：
Edward Elgar Publishing，2015：133.
〔33〕周鲠生. 国际法（上册）〔M〕. 北京：商务印书馆，1981：
70.
〔34〕 JESSUP P C. A Modern Law of Nations 〔M〕. New York：
The Macmillan Company，1948：8-10.
〔35〕詹宁斯，瓦茨. 奥本海国际法（第一卷第一分册）〔M〕.
王铁崖，译. 北京：中国大百科全书出版社，1995：10.
〔36〕徐崇利. 全球治理与跨国法律体系：硬法与软法的“中
心—外围”之构造〔J〕. 国外理论动态，2013（8）：19-28.
〔37〕 CHINKIN C. Normative Development in the International
Legal System〔M〕// Shelton D. Commitment and Compli⁃
ance：The Role of Non-binding Norms in the International
Legal System. Oxford University Press，2000：30.
〔38〕奥兰·扬. 世界事务中的治理〔M〕. 陈玉刚，薄燕，译. 上
海：上海人民出版社，2007：80-97.
〔39〕张弛. 国际法遵守理论与实践的新发展〔D〕. 武汉：武
汉大学，2012：105.
〔40〕秦娅. 联合国大会决议的法律效力〔M〕//中国国际法年
刊. 北京：中国对外翻译出版公司，1984：172.
〔41〕 GABRIEL H D. The Advantages of Soft Law in International
Commercial Law：The Role of UNIDROIT，UNCITRAL，and
the Hague Conference〔 J〕.Brook. J. Int′l L，2009（34）：3.
〔42〕 SHAW M N. International Law 〔M〕. 6th ed. Cambridge
University Press，2008：119.
〔43〕丁原洪. 如何看待西方资本主义世界的新变化？〔J〕.
红旗文稿，2017（6）：4-5.
〔44〕 FRIEDMAN M. Capitalism as Freedom 〔M〕. Chicago：
University of Chicago Press，1962：56-58.
〔45〕 SEGGER M C. Inspiration for Integration：Interpreting In⁃
ternational Trade and Investment Accords for Sustainable
Development〔 J〕. Can. J. Comp. & Contemp. L.，2017（3）：
159-216.
〔46〕 World Commission on Environment and Development. Our
Common Future 〔EB/OL〕. （1987-03-20）〔2023-06-20〕.
http：//www. un-documents. net/ocf-ov. htm.

[1]	Chen Huairui, Li Qianfu, Li Mei. Innovation in the Path of Joint Construction and Co-Construction for Party Construction in the Same#br# Type and Area of State-Owned Enterprises: "12345" Model as an Example [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2024, 9(1): 8-14.
[2]	Yang Shiqiao, Zhang Fang. On Conversation Analysis of Aphasia Based on Daily Interaction [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2024, 9(1): 15-20.
[3]	Li Xiangxiang , Xu Ye , Sun Zhaojing . Connotation, Manifestation and Experiential Enlightenment of the Historical Initiative of the CPC [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2024, 9(1): 21-27.
[4]	Wu Yuxing, Zhang Xinru. Engels' Thoughts on the Socialization of Housework and Its Realistic Enlightenment [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2024, 9(1): 28-33.
[5]	Wan Hongxia. Exploration of the Intrinsic Logic and Path of Solidly Promoting Common Prosperity in the New Era#br# from the Perspective of Allocation [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2024, 9(1): 40-45.
[6]	Gu Yao, Peng Huamin, Guo Jianhong. Research on the Path of Social Work Intervention in Public Health Crisis [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2024, 9(1): 46-52.
[7]	Zhuang Yukun, Li Na. Optimization of Cultivation Path for Full-Time Master of Education in Dali University [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2024, 9(1): 75-80.
[8]	Shi Kaixuan, Li Jing, Ling Haowei, Liu Rong, Xiao Chaojiang, Jiang Bei, . Study on Chemical Constituents of Leptodermis pilosa [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2023, 8(8): 11-14.
[9]	Li Dongyan, Yan Qing, Zheng Xiangran. Marx and Engels' Thoughts on Urban-Rural Relationship and its Contemporary Values [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2023, 8(7): 23-30.
[10]	Li Jia, Yang Yingfei. A Dynamic Study on Students' Physical Fitness inDaliUniversity [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2023, 8(6): 69-74.
[11]	Liu Zhongyi. Museum Cultural and Creative Products Design Based on the Analysis of Audience Psychological Needs：The Palace Museum as an Example [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2023, 8(3): 89-94.
[12]	Fang Li. "Rushing" and "Choosing"： Cultural Reflection on Young People Watching Videos at Double Speed [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2023, 8(3): 108-115.
[13]	Yang Liangying, Sun Yajuan. Internal Logic and Path Selection of Consolidating the Achievement of Poverty Alleviation by Education of Minorities with Less Population [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2023, 8(3): 116-122.
[14]	Ni Zhaolin, Zuo Shunwu, Liu Hongyan, Ai Zhiqiong, Nong Luming, Zhao Qiufang, Wu Qiang. Epidemiological Characteristics and Trend Prediction of Influenza in Yuxi City from 2010 to 2019 [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2023, 8(2): 78-83.
[15]	Zhang Aigu. Inheritance and Persistence： A Case Study of the Naxi Torch Festival Culture in Dali [J]. Journal of Dali University, 2023, 8(11): 7-11.